Should History Be Told In A Linear Or Nonlinear Narrative?
History
should be told in a nonlinear rather than a linear narrative. The difference
between an analysis of history and history itself must be identified. Similar
to how people listen to the scientists, not the actual science, the general
public listens to the historians not the actual history. When history is told
through a historian’s analysis, there is going to be bias as the historian seeks
to prove a point through telling the narrative. This leads to the misrepresentation
and ignorance of facts but is acceptable as already established the historian’s intent
was an analysis rather than a full account of history. Thus, linear narratives
make sense in this case.
However,
in the case which history is supposed to be told in its entirety, nonlinear narratives
are appropriate. Man always attempts to establish a cause-and-effect
relationship to understand the world. History does not always make direct sense
as seen through the existence of isolated and sporadic events. In order to
comprehend why events transpired, facts must be ignored to allow some moral or big
picture to be told. Ultimately, history gets told as a long, linear narrative which
in simple words, is unfaithful to reality. In the Postcards from the Trenches
by Allyson Booth, the author tells us how even a soldier “’could not understand
the war madness that ran about everywhere’” when returning from war. Even
those who played an integral role in history cannot understand it, thus, reality should
not be falsified to suite humans’ eager for knowledge.
I really liked how you argued both sides and showed a scenario where both methods are appropriate. I agree with how you said a nonlinear narrative is appropriate to tell history in its entirety. I believe that first-hand sources, like soldiers, are going to be un-biased and tell the events how they occurred rather than something like, memorials, where they highlight and remember the soldiers but might not always be the best way to fully understand the war or history.
ReplyDelete